Fit within scales an image until both dimensions are inside the box you specify. It keeps the original ratio and the complete frame. For example, a 4000 by 3000 landscape image fitted inside a 1920 by 1920 box becomes 1920 by 1440. The shorter side does not become 1920 because doing that would require stretching, cropping or padding.
The preset starts with that 1920-square box as an adjustable example, not a destination requirement. Use the actual bounds needed by a page, message or application. A portrait source will reach the height limit instead, while a panorama may have a much shorter output height. Check the reported dimensions before downloading. If the receiver insists on exactly matching both dimensions, Fit within may not meet its rule; choose a suitable exact crop only if removing content is acceptable.